Marshall and Morgan met their freshmen year at the University of North Florida. They were both involved in their college's Greek life community. Marshall was in Kappa Alpha Order and Morgan was in Kappa Delta. During their spring semester, Marshall met Morgan at a SAE party and shortly after attended her 19th birthday. From there, they went on their first date, which was fishing and made everything official in March 2011.

On May 22, 2021, Marshall took Morgan to the fishing spot where they went on their first date. Morgan was fishing and Marshall was on the push pole of their Hell's Bay. He was down on one knee when she turned around. While still reeling, she said "Yes!"