It was March Madness 2022 when Anjali found herself at Blue Haven East, a lively sports bar in Murray Hill. Jimmy quickly made his way over to Anjali, and the night was instantly filled with easy banter and witty remarks. But it ended all too soon, as Anjali was only visiting from Florida. Back in their everyday lives — Anjali just beginning her career and Jimmy’s already in full swing — their conversations naturally faded. A few months later, Anjali was back in the city for work. She saw Jimmy’s Instagram story of Gramercy Park and replied, commenting on how beautiful it looked. Jimmy took it as the perfect excuse to ask her out on a proper date. From that moment on, Anjali and Jimmy were inseparable, effortlessly building a life together in New York City — complete with their handsome pup, Gatsby. Fast forward to July 2025, Jimmy proposed in Gramercy Park — right where their story came full circle.