Bobby and Andie first connected online and decided to meet in person for a date. It happened to be around Halloween, Bobby had plans with friends, but didn’t want to miss the chance to meet Andie. His solution was to suggest a costume meet-up, thinking it would be a fun way to break the ice, and if things went well, Andie could join him at the Halloween party afterward. Andie was in nursing school at the time, which left her with almost no free time to prepare. With only what she had at home, she threw together the sexiest costume she could think of: Nacho Libre. They met at a Jamba Juice, where Andie was greeted by Lt. Dangle from Reno 911—complete with booty shorts and a physique like a Greek god. Meanwhile, she wore pajama pants, a swimsuit top, and a beanie-and-duct-tape mask, realizing she might have made a terrible mistake. But there was no turning back. She got out of the car, ready for her last first date. The evening began with laughter—and the laughter hasn’t stopped since.