We were both invited to a mutual friend's party. Long story short, Amanda made the first move...

Amanda thought she was having dinner in the city with her best friend. When Kelly arrived, she let her know that the plans have changed. A driver was waiting for Amanda outside of their apartment that provided her a clue to her first destination. This led Amanda to her old Upper East Side apartment. Once at the apartment, there was a second clue on the door. This clue led to their favorite coffee shop, Irving Farm. Once there, the barista gave Amanda her next clue which led to their favorite picnic spot, Central Park! Once in Central Park, there was a carriage driver waiting for her that led her through Central Park to the infamous Central Park bridge. Shea was waiting at the bridge to propose (alongside a large NYC crowd). After his beautiful proposal, Shea brought Amanda to Tavern on the Green which had her parents, his parents and Kelly there to celebrate!