Much like many a modern romance, Alyssa and Zach's began on a dating app called Tinder. Alyssa has a years-long tradition of taking photos on food-themed pool floats while eating that same food (it sounds weirder when you write it down) and had chosen a picture of her eating a piece of pizza on a pizza float as her app profile picture. When Zach came across it, he knew Alyssa didn't take herself too seriously and decided to "swipe right." After some quick-witted texts back and forth, Zach chose Walt's Hitching Post as the location for their first date. He happened to know the owner and managed to score some free peanut butter pie for dessert, much to Alyssa's delight. Was it the Zach or the pie she fell in love with that night? She'll never tell. (But it was, in fact, the pie.) The rest, as they say, is history.