Alex and Stephen planned to go see a Jeffrey Steele show at City Winery on February 8, 2019. The week before Stephen told Alex that he had a change of plans and would be going to Arkansas for a Bachelor trip. Fortunately, Stephen's mom had purchased a ticket and his cousin would use the extra one. Friday rolled around and Alex showed up at the venue not knowing what was waiting for her on the other side of the doors. As they walked in to find their seats, Stephen was waiting there and could not get down on one knee fast enough! Alex turned around and through the happy tears saw her parents standing in the corner. They celebrated with family and friends while listening to music the rest of the night.