AJ planned out (for months) the most beautiful evening with friends and family. His "story" to get Abby out of the house that night was that they were going to an annual Firefighter Union Dinner. Seemed legit to her, so she just went along for the ride. To bide the time before dinner, they were grabbing drinks in downtown Hilliard. AJ got down on one knee right then and there on the side streets of Old Hilliard and asked the big question. After the proposal, AJ surprised Abby (again) with a room full of their very close friends and family members to share in on the magical moment. -And that was all she wrote.