Get started
Best wedding cake makers in Long Island, NY

Book wedding cake makers in Long Island, NY

Discover all the wedding cake makers in Long Island for your big day

Meet Long Island bakers crafting handmade tiers inspired by the Island's own flavor

Wedding cake makers in Long Island turn a single dessert into the moment every guest reaches for their phone. Local bakers craft everything from classic tiered showstoppers to sculptural, modern designs draped in sugar flowers, plus grazing tables of mini sweets for couples who want variety over height. From the breezy elegance of a Hamptons reception to the storybook grandeur of Oheka Castle, the right cake echoes its setting. Bakers rooted in Garden City, Huntington, and Oyster Bay bring a hometown touch, often drawing on the North Fork's orchards or the Atlantic shoreline nearby. That first shared slice becomes a sweet, quiet pause worth designing with care. Browse Long Island's wedding cake makers on Zola to find your style.

Cakes
Candy and confections
Cookies and macarons
Cupcakes
Donuts
Ice cream and frozen desserts
International desserts
Mini desserts
Pastries
Pies
Puddings and custards
Novelties and other
3D sugar work
Cake toppers
Custom text
Fruit topping
Live flowers
Sugar flowers
Cake filling
Cake flavors
Cake frosting
Azerbaijani Delight
Starts at $250

Azerbaijani Delight

East Meadow, NY
5.0

We don’t just make sweets — we create memorable moments for your special day. Every layer of our baklava carries story, culture, and heritage, so your guests will savor not only the rich flavors but also the love and tradition behind every bite.

“I ordered baklava for our engagement celebration, and it was absolutely perfect. The presentation was beautiful, the...” — Farida, 9 months ago

Get a quote
Love, Li Cake
Starts at $40

Love, Li Cake

New Hyde Park, NY
5.0

All of my recipes are one of a kind and completely developed by me. I have the toughest critics in town (my family!) and I fully stand behind all of my creations! While some custom cake artists sacrifice flavor for appearance, I work my hardest to produce the best looking AND tasting cakes!

“Liana is the very best of the best, is great and easy to work and collaborate with and her products are top shelf. I...” — George M., 1 year ago

Get a quote
The Scoop Ices
Starts at $400

The Scoop Ices

Hempstead, NY
5.0

We specialize in premium, handcrafted Italian ices that add a refreshing and unique touch to weddings and special events. With vibrant flavors and a polished setup, The Scoop Ices delivers a memorable dessert experience your guests will be talking about long after the celebration.

“The Scoop Ices was an absolute pleasure to work with for our wedding. From the very first interaction, their...” — LL B., 7 months ago

Get a quote
b.Kind Sweets
Starts at $5

b.Kind Sweets

Massapequa, NY

Treat yourself to something sweet today! Fresh breads and comfort treats. Your favorite donut and so much more! If you're looking for desserts or a cake for your next gathering, send us a message! Send us a message to get started! We're here 24/7. Stay well, friends. 🧿🖤🧿

Get a quote
The Sweet Love Company
Starts at $450

The Sweet Love Company

Westbury, NY

Everything we offer has a Love theme! The Sweet Love Dessert Truck is not your average ive cream truck..it is a FULL Dessert Bar on wheels! Our extensive menu offers something for everyone! From cake pops, ice cream sundaes, brownie sundaes. Milkshakes, Soda floats, cupcakes and more, your guests will be wowed!

Get a quote
Caked By Ellie
Starts at $120

Caked By Ellie

Roslyn, NY

*** Please place order(s) a minimum of 5-6 weeks in advance due to limited availability.**** Inquiries are being taken for MARCH-MAY. *Inquiries may take approximately 2-3 weeks for a response * If it has been more than two weeks and you have not heard from me please kindly send me a DM.

Get a quote
Miri Nadler Cake Design
Starts at $1,000

Miri Nadler Cake Design

Charleston, SC
5.0

Miri documented her own palette knife cake decorating journey on Instagram. She even received requests for cake orders from her loyal followers and soon after her new business Ten Bloom Cakes was launched, which later became Miri Nadler Cake Design. Her customers not only fell in love visually with her dramatic looking cakes, but also how delicious they tasted. In addition to her signature buttercream icing recipe, Miri is also famous for her sponge cake fillings with flavors like lavender, chamomile, pink champagne, tea infused cream cheese and some all-time favorites like peanut butter and red velvet.

“We ordered one of the small Lemon Raspberry cakes for our wedding. It came in good condition and on time. It looked and...” — Faith H., 1 year ago

Get a quote
Swaadish by Neelma Quick responder
Starts at $60

Swaadish by Neelma

Gaithersburg, MD
5.0

What makes Swaadish By Neelma different is simple — there is no one else in the DMV doing what we do. We are the only luxury dessert catering specialist bringing authentic South Asian flavors to full-service wedding tables, combining the nostalgia of Rasmalai, Gulab Jamun, and Saffron with the elegance of a professionally styled, florals-forward dessert experience. I, Neelma — the owner — work closely with every single client, listening to your vision and ensuring every detail reflects your celebration beautifully. We don't just deliver desserts — we deliver a moment.

“We have been ordering from Swaadish by Neelma for years, and each experience has been consistently wonderful. The...” — Priti M., 1 year ago

Get a quote
Flourish Bakeshop & All Day Café
Starts at $700

Flourish Bakeshop & All Day Café

Glen Head, NY
5.0

Bold couples who aren’t afraid to break with tradition are the best. If you’re over the boring old cake and want to offer your guests truly memorable moments, a Flourish cake is for you. Our cakes are beautiful pieces of edible art as vibrant and unique as you are.

“Chelsea is easy to work with, professional and accommodating! Our wedding desserts were absolutely amazing and tasted so...” — Sam & B., 6 years ago

Get a quote
Dolce Bella Luxury Italian ices
Starts at $49,000

Dolce Bella Luxury Italian ices

Garden City, NY
5.0

Our customer service and our presence is always a refreshing hit at every event! Our amazing, mouth-watering, aesthetically pleasing ice is an Instagrammable worthy post to share to your story! Check us out on Instagram/Facebook!

“Dolce Bella Luxury Italian Ices was the perfect choice for our dessert needs, and we're so glad we decided to go with...” — Alexandra C., 4 months ago

Get a quote
Flo Bakes LLC

Flo Bakes LLC

North Baldwin, NY
5.0

Why Couples Love Flo Bakes Personal Touches - every dessert is crafted with your story in mind. Beautiful Presentation - desserts that taste as good as they look. Interactive Experiences - from decorating mini cakes to tasting menus, we make dessert fun and memorable. Flexible Options - from cozy at-home celebrations to grand wedding receptions, we scale to fit your vision.

“Flo Bakes LLC provided impeccable, flawless, and delicious wedding cakes and desserts for our special day. Their...” — Alexa T., 9 months ago

Get a quote
Sweet Jules Treats
Starts at $90

Sweet Jules Treats

Roslyn Heights, NY
5.0

I work with each and every client as if it is my own event! I will go above and beyond to make your day as special as you deserve! I also use top of the line ingredients and I always make sure my clients are happy. I will send you pictures along the way so you can see the progress and make sure you are in love! You always have access to call or text me at anytime of the day or night.

“Jules was so accommodating and was willing to work with us on our Golf themed engagement party. She made the cutest...” — Kristina H., 4 years ago

Get a quote
See all vendors

Last updated: August 2026

Listings on this page are regularly refreshed with the latest availability, pricing, reviews, and ratings to help you find the right match.