Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Menu
Hero Image
LeavesLeaves

Jacob Coons

and

Erin McElhoe

Jacob Coons

and

Erin McElhoe

September 20, 2025

Batesville, Indiana

How We Met

Terrible Singing and Nothing To Lose

I met Jake December 10, 2022 at Tin Roof in Cincinnati, Ohio. I was there for a girl's night out, just wanting to scream Shania Twain with my best friends on the dance floor. He was there for Santa-Con visiting his friends who had just moved back to town. I was a few tequila sodas in and I saw this tall, handsome man dancing with his friends behind me. He was so in the moment dancing without rhythm and singing off-key, he didn't notice me inching closer to him. Finally, with some liquid courage on board, I got his attention and he asked me to dance! We danced to our hearts' content, with him singing all the wrong words in my ear. When the party was over at 2am, I asked him for his number. He insisted not to give it to me, as he told me he was just in town visiting friends and he lived in TEXAS. I didn't care, I had nothing to lose and he was so much fun. He finally gave in. We kissed goodbye with all of my best friends around me ooing and awing. He left, but I had his number and I texted him quickly asking for one more kiss. He came back to the bar, conveniently staying across from it in Doug and Sophie’s brand new apartment. We went back up to the apartment and that's where the magic happened...we stayed up talking for 4 hours!! We asked questions you never would dream of asking if you were on a first date. Later in the morning after staying awake all night, he walked me out to Kira. When we hugged goodbye, I knew Jake would be important to me. I just didn't know in what capacity. I wanted to stop texting him, especially when he sent me a picture of him in his Buc-ees Santa onesie, but for some reason I couldn't! He was so fun and witty and kept me belly laughing. Texts turned into phone calls, phone calls into video calls, and after an impromptu trip to Texas, I was hooked.

The Proposal

Viva La Mexico

Parents' blessing? Check. Ring? Check. A week-long all-inclusive resort stay in Mexico with our friends? Check. I had been planning our proposal for months prior to our trip to Mexico. Me and Erin went ring shopping back in June and she gave the jeweler three different options that she was thinking of. I picked a design, picked a stone, and picked up her new favorite piece of jewelry the next month, all without her knowing. For those of you who don't know, I am terrible with secrets and even worse with hiding ANYTHING from Erin. Somehow I managed to not only pick up and hide the ring for 3 months, but I also came up with the plan for Mexico. The date was set for October 8th, a nice candle-lit dinner on the beach. I recruited Doug and Sophie to assist with the execution, with the plan being the girls getting ready for some nice beach pictures while me and Doug are scoping out the dinner location. The girls would come and meet us and that's when Erin would see that there was something special in the works. Well, as with most plans, they never actually go to plan…Hurricane Milton was brewing. Milton was supposed to pass by Cancun the day of my planned proposal. Time to scramble for a Plan B. Conveniently enough, we had scheduled a catamaran for Monday the 7th. We would be taken to Isla Mujeres and what was supposed to be a beautiful beach. Well, Milton strikes again. Our excursion got postponed to later in the week. When me and Doug went to the desk to try and hash out our excursion plans, I told him it's happening today. I can't carry this secret any longer and if I keep waiting for the right moment, it's never going to come. So enter Plan C. The weather Monday night wasn't terrible, but I wasn't going to have the sunset I really wanted. I texted Sophie asking her to talk to the other girls (minus Erin) and propose that we go to the beach and get some pictures that night. Erin was reluctant to get ready that night after a day of fun in the sun, but thankfully she did. I knew she would want to look great for the pictures to come, even if she didn't know at the time why they'd be so important. The group meets up and we walk down to the beach. Me and Doug stayed in the back and I got a little pep-talk as I moved the ring into my pocket. When we get down to the beach, everyone gets some pictures. Last ones up, me and Erin. We do our couples pictures, and when we finish she says "Ok that's enough. Let's go." But I grab her arm and ask her if I can ask her something. What followed was a blur of tears, shaky words, and lots of nerves. Once I finally get the words out that I wanted to say, I start to get down on a knee and pull the ring out of my pocket. I got the yes I was hoping for, and we were able to spend the rest of our trip in paradise engaged!

Footer image

Schedule

The Wedding Website of Erin McElhoe and Jacob Coons

Saturday, September 20, 2025

Ceremony

4:00 pm

Romweber Party Place, Batesville, IN
7 S Eastern Avenue, Batesville, IN 47006

Reception

5:00 pm - 11:00 pm

Romweber Party Place, Batesville, IN
7 S Eastern Avenue, Batesville, IN 47006

Travel

The Wedding Website of Erin McElhoe and Jacob Coons
Welcome to Batesville, Indiana- Erin's hometown! We're so lucky and appreciative to have loved ones who are willing to travel to us to help celebrate. Please use the following information to guide your stay.

Hotel

The Sherman Inn

35 South Main Street, Batesville, IN 47006
 812-934-1000

The Sherman is one of the oldest buildings in Batesville that sits in the heart of downtown. It is also conveniently located a walkable distance from the venue! We recommend booking early as this is a smaller hotel and we have limited rooms blocked off for the night before the wedding and the wedding night. Call the number and mention the wedding of Erin and Jake Coons when you make your reservation to receive the discounted rate!

Hotel

Best Western Batesville

1030 Indiana 229, Batesville, IN 47006
 812-934-6262

The Best Western has many rooms available for our guests! Please call ahead to book your reservation here and mention the wedding of Erin and Jake Coons in order to get a discounted rate. There are many options available as far as double queen bed rooms and king bed singles.

Hotel

Quality Inn I-74 Batesville

112 Indiana 46, Batesville, IN 47006
 812-934-6185

This hotel is another option! Although we have not personally stayed here, we recommend using this option if our other discounted rooms are no longer available.

Flight

Indianapolis International Airport

Indianapolis International Airport (IND) has plenty of incoming flights and is about an hour from Batesville. There are options for rental cars available at the airport, although we recommend Enterprise as the quickest and easiest option. There are also Ubers and Lyft available.

Flight

Cincinnati/Northern KY Airport

Cincinnati Airport (CVG) is about 50 minutes from Batesville and also has plenty of options for rental cars, Uber, and Lyft.

Registry

272d7a43-6f7e-425e-861e-5535eb9f23f6
Your presence is the most meaningful to us, but if you are feeling particularly generous, these are a few things we'd love to have as newlyweds.
Crate&Barrel

Wedding Party

The Wedding Website of Erin McElhoe and Jacob Coons
Meet the people who are most near and dear to us! We are so happy to have them be apart of our day.

Emily Vogt

Matron of Honor

TJ Caldwell

Best Man

Kira Treesh

Matron of Honor

Doug Strange

Best Man

Olivia McElhoe

Bridesmaid

Justin Coons

Groomsman

Grace Heppner

Bridesmaid

Justin Lewis

Groomsman

Lillie Sitterding

Bridesmaid

Austin Befort

Groomsman

Kaylee Jardine

Bridesmaid

Bailey Zeldin

Groomsman

Shaunte Higginbotham

Bridesmaid

Eric Ellerhorst

Groomsman

Sophie Strange

Bridesmaid

Charlie Christianson

Groomsman

Molly Garcia

Bridesmaid

Daniel Coons

Father of the Groom

Violet Coons

Mother of the Groom

Katherine McElhoe

Mother of the Bride

Aaron McElhoe

Father of the Bride

Linda Crum

Flower Girl

Oliver & Case Vogt

Ring Bearers

Carl

Our Dog

Right before Jake surprised me with an engagement party with our family and friends!
Some engagement photos on the beach in Mexico
The night of the proposal!

FAQs

The Wedding Website of Erin McElhoe and Jacob Coons
If you have any other questions than what we have listed here, please reach out to Erin or Jake directly.
Question

Are children invited?

Answer

While we adore your little ones, we'd like to give our guests the opportunity to have a night out child-free. For that reason, our wedding is adults only, aside from family, and we appreciate you making arrangements to leave the kids at home. We hope you understand and enjoy the night off!

Question

Can I bring a date?

Answer

Although we'd love to offer a plus one to all guests, we are only able to accomodate those guests formally invited on your wedding invitation. If you received a plus one they will appear when you RSVP. We appreciate your understanding and can't wait to celebrate with you!

Question

Is there a dress code?

Answer

Dress code for our wedding will be formal to semi-formal attire. We'd love to see our family and friends dress up with us! We encourage guests to consider wearing suits and long dresses to cocktail length dresses. We kindly ask you to avoid wearing colors reserved for the bride - white, creams, ivories. Please contact Erin or Jake with any questions!

Question

What time should I arrive?

Answer

Please arrive 15-30 minutes before the ceremony begins to allow time to find a seat and settle in for our big day!

Question

Will there be an open bar?

Answer

We have chosen three drinks that represent us individually and as a couple. Our "His," "Hers" and "Ours" drinks are on us for the night! We will also have beer and wine open to our guests that we will take care of. A cash bar will be offered as well if you would like a certain cocktail. If you will be drinking, please drink responsibly and have a ride arranged to get home safely!

Question

Will the ceremony and reception be indoors or outdoors?

Answer

Both the ceremony and reception will be indoors! Our venue has a lovely patio if you need to slip out and enjoy some fresh air. Conveniently, our ceremony and reception are both being held at Romweber Party Place.

RSVP

Please let us know if you plan to attend our wedding by August 1st, 2025 so we can have an accurate count for our vendors! After this deadline, we can no longer accept any RSVPs.

Please enter the first and last name of one member of your party below.
If you're responding for you and a guest (or your family), you'll be able to RSVP for your entire group on the next page.

Ex. Sarah Fortune (not The Fortune Family or Dr. & Mr. Fortune)