When Caroline moved to Stamford after joining her family's business, she decided it was time to give Hinge in Connecticut a try. The very first profile that appeared? A handsome guy named Nick who looked awfully familiar. She immediately thought he was adorable and swiped right, commenting on his love of Tolkien and playing guitar. But there was something else she couldn't shake... A couple of months earlier, Caroline had spotted a cute guy while having dinner with her dad at their favorite restaurant, Sunset Grille in Norwalk, Connecticut. He was there on a date, and although they never exchanged a word, she came home telling her family about the handsome mystery guy she couldn't stop thinking about. Fast forward to Caroline and Nick's first date. She finally had to ask: "So... have you ever been to Sunset Grille?" Nick confidently replied, "No." Well... there went that theory! Caroline accepted that Nick simply wasn't the Sunset Grille guy, and the mystery remained unsolved. Six months later, during their very first summer together as boyfriend and girlfriend, they were making a summer bucket list when Caroline excitedly said, "We have to check out Sunset Grille!" Nick paused. "Is that the place in Norwalk with the mini golf course... in the marina?" Caroline's jaw dropped. "YES!" Nick immediately pulled up his old text messages to verify when he had been there. Caroline searched her camera roll for the selfie she'd taken with her dad at dinner. Sure enough... Nick was the Sunset Grille guy all along. Somehow, fate had placed them in the same restaurant months before they officially met, then brought them together again with one swipe on Hinge. Now, the Sunset Grille guy has become Caroline's best friend, greatest adventure, and forever person. We can't wait to make it official, surrounded by the people we love most, in our favorite place in the world... Vermont!