The Best Wedding Cake Bakeries in Orwell, OH

The Best Wedding Cake Bakeries in Orwell, OH

How do we sort results, including Sponsored Ads and personalized results?


12 Wedding Cakes & Desserts in Orwell, OH

Up to $158
Quick responder
Bakehouse Creations (Gluten Free) 

5.0

  • Starts at $144
  • Serves Orwell, OH

When a family member was diagnosed with Celiac Disease, we made it our mission to create treasured family favorites Gluten-Free so we could all enjoy delicious treats together! Word got out and BAM... we're in business. We strive to create high-quality baked goods that bring joy to our customers' lives. We use only the best ingredients and our recipes are made from scratch. We take pride in our products and strive to exceed your expectations. We think Grandma would approve!

I had a wonderful experience working with Bakehouse Creations for our wedding. Their communication was great - they were informative, helpful, and responsive to all of my questions. The quality of their work exceeded my expectations; the cakes and desserts were absolutely delicious. They were also very accommodating, making sure to address any special requests. The end result was stunning, and people are still talking about the quality of their bakery items! I would highly recommend Bakehouse Creations to any couple looking for an exceptional wedding cake or dessert vendor.
Jessica, a year ago
Quick responder
Cowboy Creamery 

5.0

  • Starts at $3
  • Serves Orwell, OH

Cowboy Creamery is in scenic Middlefield, Ohio, serving up scoops, signature Stampedes, floats, hand-spun milkshakes, ice cream cakes, and specialty desserts made with premium ingredients and plenty of hometown charm. Known for its Western flair and creative flavors, Cowboy Creamery offers everything from hand-dipped and soft-serve ice cream to catering options like their vintage Ice Cream Truck, Wagon Wheel Ice Cream Sandwiches, dessert platters, and freezer rentals for events. Whether you’re celebrating a wedding, corporate gathering, or community event, Cowboy Creamery delivers a fun, memorable, and sweet experience for every guest.

Cowboy Creamery was a pleasure to work with for our wedding desserts. From our first conversation, they were easy to understand and thoughtfully answered all of our questions. Their team was hardworking, quick, and efficient in creating the perfect dessert spread for our big day. The quality of their work was fantastic, and we felt we received great value for the cost. Our guests raved about it all the perfect ending to our wedding celebration.
Casey, a month ago
TrendlineTrending
The Confectionary Cupboard 

5.0

  • Serves Orwell, OH

It started with a hobby, witch turned into a dream, and eventually became a reality for the empty nester of our company. The quaint specialty shop opened its doors in December 2009 and features specialty cupcakes and cakes. Each of our cupcakes is baked fresh each morning then topped with our special recipe buttercreams, made each week in house with quality products and fresh butter. Everything is in the details , down to the hand tied ribbon on the boxes.

Working with Confectionary Cupboard on our cake was such a lovely and easy experience, from the tasting to finally seeing our gorgeous cake in person. They understood and executed exactly what we asked for and were so sweet and accommodating in the process!
Angie R., 2 months ago
Quick responder
Sugar in THE LAND 

5.0

  • Starts at $72
  • Serves Orwell, OH

My passion for baking spans decades! Sugar in THE LAND creates elegant, custom desserts for all occasions. Known for clean aesthetics, attention to detail, and high-quality ingredients, I craft treats that are as stunning as they are delicious. From modern cakesicles and cupcakes to full dessert tables, I work with each client to bring their vision to life. Serving [your location], Sugar in THE LAND ensures a polished experience and presentation. Whether for an intimate gathering or large event, we deliver elevated desserts that leave a lasting impression.

Sugar in THE LAND was a fantastic choice for my desserts. Their communication was quick and they asked detailed questions to ensure they fully understood our vision. The treats they delivered were not only beautiful, but absolutely delicious as well. They didn't just drop off the desserts, but meticulously set up an amazing display that wowed all of our guests. We couldn't have asked for a better vendor to help make my special day so sweet.
Aimee, 3 months ago
TrendlineTrending
Crumbl Cookies 

5.0

  • Starts at $1
  • Serves Orwell, OH

Everyone’s favorite cookie at your event! We offer a large selection of flavor options in both our full size and mini cookies as well as a constantly evolving array of other desserts! Whether you are looking for a cake alternative or an edible favor, Crumbl is a sweet addition to your special day or shower!

Crumbl Cookies was an excellent choice for our wedding desserts. Their communication style was professional, helpful, and responsive throughout the entire process. The quality of their work and the value they provided was top-notch - the gourmet cookies they made for our wedding were not only delicious, but also beautifully presented. We were able to customize the flavors to our liking, and they ensured the cookies were ready on time without any issues. All of our guests raved about how amazing the cookies were and we were thrilled to have them as part of our special day.
Katie C., 10 months ago
Quick responder
Gailz Goodiez 

5.0

  • Starts at $3
  • Serves Orwell, OH

Gailz Goodiez has catered over 150 weddings with delicious cake pops! With over 30 flavors to choose from, they will certainly please all of your guests. Gluten-free, Vegan, Keto, nut-free and sugar free are all available. Each cake pop comes individually wrapped and tied with either a twisty or a colored ribbon ($1 more per dozen). They are baked and decorated to order and are sold individually (for $3 each) or by the dozen (for $24) Cookies and other goodies are also available. This is a home based business and all products are home produced under the Ohio Cottage Law. I do not make wedding cakes.

I worked with Gail for my bridal shower and wedding. Fantastic experience and delicious cake pops. They were all gone at the wedding before i blinked!!
Hannah M., 2 years ago
Quick responder
Scratch Bakery 

5.0

  • Starts at $3
  • Serves Orwell, OH

Scratch Bakery began in 2016, as my passion for baking grew into a full time “job.” I enjoy working with my clients to create the perfect treats for their occasions. My main focus is taste, taste, taste - using quality ingredients and made all from scratch. If something looks wonderful, but doesn’t taste good, I do not use it. Part of the reason I began baking and decorating was due to unmet expectations. I don’t ever want my clients to feel as though they didn’t receive what they were hoping for.

Awarded Best of Zola
Jill at Scratch bakery truly brought our vision for wedding desserts to life! We wanted more than just a standard wedding cake and had unique flavors in mind, she was positive and excited to work with us to make our “his and hers favorites” dessert table a realty. In addition to our two tiered wedding cake (that was maple bacon bourbon flavored and AMAZING!), Scratch also handled all of the sweets for our dessert table which included over 250 mini cupcakes in fun flavors such as salted caramel, wedding cake, chocolate peanut butter and red velvet. We also had chocolate chip cookies, key lime pie bars and her famous Carmelita’s (they are to die for). We use Scratch Bakery for all our family birthdays and special occasions now, truly such a memorable part of our wedding day that guests still talk about three years later.
Kristen & A., 4 years ago
TrendlineTrending
Any Way You Ice It 

5.0

  • Serves Orwell, OH

Any Way You Ice It was founded by the imagination of my mother, Janene Housley, and I. I grew up around the creation of wedding cakes by my mom. From the baking to the delivery, I was always intrigued. I attended the International Culinary Arts and Sciences Institute. I graduated top of my class with a two-year degree, a diploma and a Pastry Chef title. I suit the traditional and the modern bride’s needs …if you can dream it I will make it! Any Way You Ice It is a designer cake business. Each and every cake is a unique designer cake, an edible work of art. “From Imagination to Creation”, I will work with you to create your perfect cake.

Kelly was great to work with! I am a Baking & Pastry Arts student, so I had a very specific vision for my wedding cake and cupcakes. Kelly understood immediately what I wanted, provided a perfect sketch of what I had described in words, so I knew she had my idea firmly in her head, and then delivered in spades. The cake and cupcakes were absolutely BEAUTIFUL, and delicious, too! Everyone raved about the cupcakes so much that I made myself try one even though I was already stuffed from dinner and cake! I would 1000% recommend Any Way You Ice It!
Kati W., 4 years ago
GemHidden gem
Canela Bakeshop 

5.0

  • Starts at $8 per serving
  • Serves Orwell, OH

Canela Bakeshop is a boutique custom wedding cake bakery, and are particularly drawn to creating designs with a unique artistic flair. We specialize in buttercream work, and can accommodate custom flavor requests and some dietary restrictions. We work one cake at a time, meaning your beautiful custom creation is the only thing on our mind!

Full disclosure - we were sold on Canela bakery once we saw her name as our beautiful maltipoo puppy is named Canela But once we saw her work and tasted her cake, it was obvious that she is a force to be reckoned with. We had a tasting with her prior to our big day and the cake was exceptional. It was moist with great consistency and the frosting was divine. And her aesthetic is absolutely spectacular. We had Canela bakery provide us a beautiful lemon flavored cake for our pre-wedding Mehndi henna party and it was a huge hit. Then the three tiered cake we had for our wedding was the best tasting wedding cake we have ever eaten (and many, many guests agreed!) It was a almond cake with cherry filling with pink champagne frosting. My mouth waters just writing this review. Canela bakery is exceptional and we recommend it to anyone and everyone!
Lindsay & P., 5 years ago
TrendlineTrending
April Mae Cupcakes 
  • Starts at $36
  • Serves Orwell, OH

I specialize in cupcakes and small cakes with classic flavors and exciting twists. I work with American Buttercream, Swiss Buttercream, and Italian Buttercream, but I don’t do fondant. I’m located in a suburb of Cleveland, Ohio, and I offer delivery!

Location flexible? Discover cakes & desserts near Orwell, OH